The Publisher Will Probably Change This Title • Last activity 12/Mar

For advanced writers familiar with concept, character, theme, structure, scene execution, and voice. Best suited for the traditional YA/adult speculative markets, but open to most genres in those age categories. We're not the best fit for historical.



Book-length works (Low magic/fantasy, Fantasy, Paranormal, Science Fiction, Horror, Mystery, Crime, and Thriller)


Young Adult (Mystery, Crime, or Thriller, Low magic/fantasy, Fantasy, Paranormal, Science Fiction, Horror)


Traditional Publication

Admissions Policies

Please check our profile pages to see if our projects and critique styles are what you are looking for. To apply, please submit a list of your most recent reads, a pitch, and a 1000-word writing sample of the project you want critiqued. If we think we might be a good fit we will do a test critique to see of our critiquing styles are compatible.

What we're looking for in members

Familiarity with recent YA sci-fi/fantasy debuts and a positive attitude. "Accountability is the glue that ties commitment to results." --Bob Proctor

Inactivity Policy

Critiques must be made even if pages are not submitted, otherwise we will respectfully part ways.